Punished by Ann-Helén Laestadius is about five Sami indigenous children being forced to attend a government-run boarding school. In the 1950s in Sweden, there was a mandate that all the children of Sami reindeer hunters had to attend these re-education nomads boarding schools. Seven-year-olds Jon-Ante, Else-Maj, Nilsa, Marge, and Anne-Risten are attending the school together for the first time.
The children are forbidden to speak their native language and encouraged to learn Swedish norms and culture. They can only visit their families occasionally for some holidays. Their parents are not aware of the abuse the children face. The ones that do speak up, face repercussions that leave scars that are not just skin deep and they have lasting effects.
Thirty years later, the children have chosen different paths after spending their youth at the nomad school. Else-Maj is proud of her Sami heritage but she seeks solace in religion. Anne-Risten prefers to go by Anne to hide that she is Sami. Nilsa is a reindeer herder like his father and has a lot of anger issues like his grandfather. Jon-Ante struggles with a deformity he had received in school. Marge has an adopted daughter from Colombia, and she struggles to know if she made the right choice of taking her from her homeland.
While the five adults are still struggling with the past, they come across the housemother, Rita, from the nomad school. They had once feared her as children and she made their lives miserable. However, she is now a frail old woman who believes that God is on her side. She thinks that she didn’t do anything wrong when she was the housemother. They have never forgotten or forgiven her and now, they will need to decide how they act now that the roles have been reversed.
The novel is told from alternating narrators and time periods. The novel started off interesting but then it felt boring. It was interesting to see how the children were treated and how that affected them as adults. However, the re-emergence of Rita in their lives was a very small part of the story. I thought some of the characters would have more interaction or there would be dialogue/story about them coping with their feelings of seeing Rita again after thirty years.
I think I would have enjoyed the book if there were fewer characters. It was hard focusing on the many different characters along with their past, and present, and how they were connected. I felt like if there were fewer characters we could have connected more to the characters and their struggles. I would be open to reading more stories about Sami culture and people but I would be hesitant to pick up another book by the author.